Addressing Employee Resistance to IT System Rollout
Alex Vance and Sam Brooks discuss the initial success of a Spanish pilot rollout for a new IT system, focusing on manager concerns about job security and professional identity. They review early results, identify change ambassadors, and prepare to expand the initiative to other locations.
What you’ll be able to do
- By the end of this self-study, you will be able to identify key concerns raised by stakeholders during change management discussions.
- By the end of this self-study, you will be able to extract specific roles and responsibilities assigned to team members in the dialogue.
- By the end of this self-study, you will be able to summarize communication strategies proposed to maintain stakeholder trust and transparency.
Dialogue
Beginner version
Alex Vance
Good morning, Sam. I am happy we can talk again. How was your meeting with the Spanish managers?
Sam
Good morning, Alex Vance. It was very good. Better than we thought. The managers were honest. They talked about their jobs. They also said they are scared. They are scared about losing who they are at work.
Alex Vance
That is important. This is not just about changing how we work. It is about how people feel. They want to feel important. What did you learn?
Sam
We learned three things. One: they want to keep their jobs. They also want to feel needed. Two: they want to know what stays the same. Three: they want to help decide what their jobs will look like.
Alex Vance
Good. That helps us. We need to say: your work is still important. We are just changing some things. Did you talk to them about new jobs?
Sam
Yes. We told them about some ideas. They can move to other jobs at the same level. They can learn new skills. Their jobs can mix old and new tasks. We said: we are not removing jobs. We are changing them. They felt better. Some people want to help write the new job descriptions.
Alex Vance
That is great. It means they trust us more. Did you find people who can help spread good news about the change?
Sam
Yes. Two people: Taylor Nash and Morgan Frost. People like them. They are happy about the change. They said yes to helping us.
Alex Vance
Good. We will give them key information. We will give them common questions and answers. We will give them a short training. They will help people trust the change.
Sam
Our Talent team will help them too. I gave Taylor and Morgan our five key messages. They liked them. But some managers have a question. Who can they call if something goes wrong after the pilot?
Alex Vance
That is a good question. We need to tell people who to contact. We need to say we will answer fast. We need to show this is a team effort. It is not just orders from the top.
Sam
Yes. That helps people feel safe. Also, the IT team starts at two places next week. We are watching how people use the new system. Westbrook is a little slow. But the training feedback is getting better.
Alex Vance
Good. When people like the training, they use the system more. Let's collect the numbers. Let's share them with the teams in Eastgate and Hillcrest. They will see the change is working.
Sam
OK. I will write a short report. It will show training numbers, how people feel, and how the ambassadors are helping.
Alex Vance
Good. This keeps things moving. Other places can learn from it too. Did anything go wrong?
Sam
One small problem. Hillcrest asks why Westbrook got extra help. They feel we forgot them.
Alex Vance
We need to fix that. We must explain that Westbrook is a test site. It is not special. The plan will work for all places. I will write a message. I will say: Westbrook helps us build the plan. Hillcrest and Eastgate will get the same help.
Sam
I agree. Also, Taylor Nash and Morgan Frost wrote posts on the Verolane Group platform. They said why they support the change. People liked the posts. They were simple and real.
Alex Vance
That is the best kind of message. Let's use their words in our emails and short videos.
Sam
We are already doing that. Two short videos are almost ready. They are simple and honest. People like that.
Alex Vance
Great. Are you ready for the next step? Next week we want to start in Hillcrest and Eastgate too.
Sam
Westbrook is ready. If people still feel good, we can move forward. Taylor Nash and Morgan Frost will show other people how it works. But we need the top managers in Hillcrest and Eastgate to say yes.
Alex Vance
I will talk to their leaders soon. I will tell them what we learned in Westbrook. I will share our messages, our early results, the ambassador stories, and the steps for raising problems.
Sam
That will help a lot. I will tell our local HR teams to get ready for your meetings.
Alex Vance
Good. One more thing. Some managers do not understand the new structure. Who reports to who. Can we make a simple picture of the old and new teams and jobs?
Sam
Yes. I will ask our design team to draw a simple chart. It will show old jobs and new jobs. Even a basic one will help people understand.
Alex Vance
Good. Let's try it in Westbrook first. If it helps, we use it in Hillcrest and Eastgate too.
Sam
I will try to finish the first version today. Then we can look at it together and make it better.
Alex Vance
Great. You did a lot this week. We went from worry to progress. Now we need to keep going. We need to do the same in other places.
Sam
The whole team did this. And thank you, Alex Vance. You helped us say the right things. You helped people feel listened to.
Alex Vance
That is what good change looks like. See you next week. But call me if something urgent happens.
Sam
I will. Let's keep going. Things are going well.
Intermediate version
Alex Vance
Good morning, Sam. I'm glad we could meet again so quickly. How did the meeting with the Spanish managers go?
Sam
Good morning, Alex Vance. It went really well, better than we expected. The managers were open and honest. They didn't just talk about their job roles. They also shared real worries, especially about losing their sense of professional identity.
Alex Vance
That's really important. It shows this is more than just an operational change, it's about making people feel valued and included. What were the main things you took away from the meeting?
Sam
Three key themes came up. First, job security matters a lot, but they also want to feel essential. Second, they need to know what will stay the same and where they still have control. Third, they want to play an active part in shaping their new roles, not just be told what to do.
Alex Vance
That fits well with what we're trying to achieve. Our messages need to make clear that their contribution still matters during this transition. Did you talk to them about possible future roles?
Sam
Yes. We shared some early ideas: moving sideways to similar roles, learning new skills, and having mixed responsibilities. We made it clear we're not cutting jobs, we're updating them. That helped ease their worries, and some people even offered to help write the new job descriptions.
Alex Vance
That's a good sign. It means trust in the process is growing. Did you spot anyone who could act as a change ambassador?
Sam
Yes. Two people stood out: Taylor Nash and Morgan Frost. They're well respected and already have a positive attitude about the change. Both have agreed to join the change network.
Alex Vance
Great. We'll make sure they have clear key messages, a list of common questions and answers, and a short training session. They'll play an important role in building trust around the change.
Sam
I'll get our Talent team to support them. I also shared the five-point message we put together, it landed well. One question did come up, though: some managers want to know who they should contact if problems come up after the pilot.
Alex Vance
That's a fair concern. We need to clearly explain how to raise issues, name the right contacts, and promise quick responses. We have to show that this is a shared effort, not just instructions from the top.
Sam
Definitely. That gives people more confidence. On another note, the IT team is launching at two sites next week. We're tracking how well people are adopting the system. Westbrook is moving a bit slowly, but the feedback on training is improving.
Alex Vance
That's encouraging. When people find the training useful, they're more willing to use the system. Let's pull together these early results and share them with the leadership teams in Eastgate and Hillcrest to show the change is moving forward.
Sam
Good idea. I'll put together a short report covering training numbers, how people are feeling about the change, and how the ambassadors are getting involved.
Alex Vance
Perfect. That keeps things moving and gives other regions something to learn from. Have there been any unexpected problems?
Sam
One small issue: Hillcrest is asking why Westbrook got extra support. They feel like they've been left out.
Alex Vance
We need to deal with that. We should explain clearly that Westbrook is a pilot site, not a preferred one. We're building a plan that will work for all regions. I'll write a message saying: Westbrook is helping us shape this initiative, and Hillcrest and Eastgate will benefit just as much.
Sam
I agree. On a positive note, Taylor Nash and Morgan Frost posted on the Verolane Group platform about why they're supporting the change. The posts were very well received because they were genuine and easy to understand.
Alex Vance
That's exactly the kind of communication we need. Let's turn those posts into short stories we can use in internal emails and videos.
Sam
We've already started on that. Two short videos are being edited right now. They're simple but authentic, and that's what people connect with.
Alex Vance
Good. Do you feel ready for the next phase? The goal for next week is to prepare Hillcrest and Eastgate for a similar rollout.
Sam
Westbrook is ready. If the mood stays positive, we can move ahead. Taylor Nash and Morgan Frost will help show others how the process works. We just need senior management in Hillcrest and Eastgate to get on board.
Alex Vance
I'll talk to their leaders soon. I'll explain what we learned from Westbrook and share useful resources like the messaging guide, early results, ambassador stories, and the steps for raising concerns.
Sam
That will be a big help. I'll let our local HR teams know to expect your meetings.
Alex Vance
Good. One last thing, some department heads are still confused about the new reporting structure. Even though we talk about influence rather than control, could we create a simple visual showing the new roles and teams?
Sam
Yes. I'll ask the design team to put together a basic diagram comparing the old and new structures, including job titles. Even a simple version will make things much clearer.
Alex Vance
Good. Let's test it in Westbrook first. If it works well, we can adjust it for Hillcrest and Eastgate.
Sam
I'll try to have a first draft ready by the end of today. Then we can work on it together and improve it.
Alex Vance
Fantastic. You've made a lot of progress in just one week. We've moved from worry to real momentum. The challenge now is to keep that going and roll out the plan in other regions.
Sam
It's really a team effort. And thank you, Alex Vance, for helping us find the right way to communicate and for making sure people felt heard.
Alex Vance
That's what effective change is all about. I'll see you next week for our review, but if anything urgent comes up before then, please give me a call.
Sam
Will do. Until then, let's keep this positive energy going.
Advanced version
Alex Vance
Good morning, Sam. I’m pleased we could reconvene so soon. How did the meeting with the Spanish managers go?
Sam
Good morning, Alex Vance. It went exceptionally well-surpassing our expectations. The managers were candid. They didn’t merely discuss job roles; they articulated profound anxieties, particularly the fear of losing their professional identity.
Alex Vance
That’s crucial. It underscores that the issue transcends mere operational adjustments-it’s about preserving their sense of value and belonging. What were the key takeaways?
Sam
Three primary themes emerged. First: job security is paramount, but more importantly, they seek to feel indispensable. Second: they need clarity on what will remain constant and where they retain autonomy. Third: they want to actively shape their evolving roles rather than simply receiving directives.
Alex Vance
That aligns perfectly with our objectives. Our messaging must now emphasize, 'Your contribution remains vital as we transition.' Did you explore potential future roles with them?
Sam
Yes. We presented preliminary concepts: lateral moves at the same level, upskilling opportunities, and blended responsibilities. We assured them, 'We aren’t eliminating positions; we’re evolving them.' This alleviated their concerns significantly. Some even volunteered to co-author the new job descriptions.
Alex Vance
That’s encouraging. It signals growing trust in the process. Did you identify potential change ambassadors?
Sam
Indeed. Two individuals stood out: Taylor Nash and Morgan Frost. Both are well-regarded and already exhibit a positive attitude. They’ve agreed to join the change network.
Alex Vance
Excellent. We’ll equip them with clear talking points, FAQs, and a brief training session. They’ll be instrumental in fostering trust in the change.
Sam
I’ll enlist our Talent team to support them. I also provided them with the five-point message we developed-it resonated well. One question did arise, though: some managers are asking who to contact if they encounter issues post-pilot.
Alex Vance
That’s a valid concern. We need to clearly outline the process for raising concerns, designate the appropriate contacts, and guarantee timely responses. We must demonstrate that this is a collaborative effort, not a top-down mandate.
Sam
Absolutely. That fosters a sense of security. Meanwhile, the IT team is launching in two sites next week. We’re monitoring adoption rates. Westbrook is still a bit sluggish, but training feedback is improving.
Alex Vance
That’s a positive indicator. When users find training engaging, they’re more receptive to the system. Let’s compile these early metrics and share them with the leadership in Eastgate and Hillcrest. It will demonstrate the change is gaining traction.
Sam
Agreed. I’ll prepare a concise report covering training numbers, sentiment analysis, and ambassador participation.
Alex Vance
Perfect. This sustains momentum and provides valuable insights for other regions. Any unforeseen challenges?
Sam
One minor issue: Hillcrest is questioning why Westbrook received special support. They feel overlooked.
Alex Vance
That needs addressing. We must clarify that Westbrook is a pilot, not a preferential case. We’re developing a framework applicable to all regions. I’ll draft a communication stating: 'Westbrook is helping shape this initiative. Hillcrest and Eastgate will benefit equally.'
Sam
I concur. In fact, we published two testimonials from Taylor Nash and Morgan Frost on the Verolane Group platform, explaining their motivation. The posts were very well-received due to their authenticity and simplicity.
Alex Vance
That’s the ideal type of messaging. Let’s adapt these into short narratives for our internal emails and videos.
Sam
Already in progress. Two short videos are currently being edited. They’re straightforward, but genuine-which is what resonates.
Alex Vance
Great. Are you comfortable with the next phase? Next week, we aim to prepare Hillcrest and Eastgate for a similar rollout.
Sam
Westbrook is prepared. If sentiment remains positive, we can proceed. Taylor Nash and Morgan Frost will assist in demonstrating the process to others. We just need buy-in from senior management in Hillcrest and Eastgate.
Alex Vance
I’ll speak with their leaders soon. I’ll explain that Westbrook provided valuable lessons, and now we can share resources like the messaging brief, initial results, ambassador stories, and clear escalation procedures.
Sam
That will be immensely helpful. I’ll inform our local HR teams to anticipate your meetings.
Alex Vance
Excellent. One final point-some department heads are still unclear about the new reporting structure. Even if we emphasize 'influence over control,' can we create a simple visual of the new roles and teams?
Sam
Yes. I’ll request our design team to draft a basic diagram-comparing old and new structures with job titles. Even a rudimentary version will aid comprehension.
Alex Vance
Good. Let’s pilot it in Westbrook first. If it proves effective, we can adapt it for Hillcrest and Eastgate.
Sam
I’ll aim to have the first draft ready by the end of today. Then we can refine it collaboratively.
Alex Vance
Fantastic. You’ve achieved a great deal in just one week. We’ve transitioned from anxiety to progress. Now, the challenge is to maintain this momentum and replicate the plan elsewhere.
Sam
That’s due to the entire team. And thank you, Alex Vance, for helping us find the right words and ensuring people felt heard.
Alex Vance
That’s the essence of meaningful change. I’ll see you next week for our next review-but if anything urgent arises, please don’t hesitate to call.
Sam
I will. Until then, let’s keep this positive momentum going.
Check your understanding
1. What were the three primary themes that emerged from the meeting with the Spanish managers?
Show answer
The three themes were: job security and feeling indispensable, clarity on what remains constant and where they retain autonomy, and the desire to actively shape their evolving roles rather than just receiving directives.
2. How did Sam reassure the managers regarding their positions during the meeting?
Show answer
Sam reassured them by stating that positions were not being eliminated but were being evolved, which significantly alleviated their concerns.
3. Who were identified as potential change ambassadors, and what qualities did they possess?
Show answer
Taylor Nash and Morgan Frost were identified as potential change ambassadors. They are well-regarded, exhibit a positive attitude, and have agreed to join the change network.
4. What specific support will the Talent team provide to the change ambassadors?
Show answer
The dialogue does not specify the exact support the Talent team will provide, only that Sam will enlist them to support the ambassadors.
5. Why is Hillcrest questioning the special support given to Westbrook?
Show answer
Hillcrest feels overlooked because they are questioning why Westbrook received special support, perceiving it as preferential treatment rather than a pilot.
6. What communication does Alex Vance plan to draft to address Hillcrest's concerns?
Show answer
Alex Vance plans to draft a communication stating that Westbrook is helping shape the initiative and that Hillcrest and Eastgate will benefit equally.
7. What visual aid is Sam going to create to help department heads understand the new reporting structure?
Show answer
Sam will request the design team to draft a basic diagram comparing old and new structures with job titles.
Grammar practice (mixed)
Tenses
By the time the global rollout begins, the HR team ____ the feedback synthesis from the Spanish managers.
Show answer & why
will have completed · 💡 The future perfect tense is required to describe an action that will be finished before a specific point in the future.
Prepositionsself-check
The managers were candid about their anxieties, particularly the fear ____ losing their professional identity.
Show answer & why
of · 💡 The noun 'fear' is standardly followed by the preposition 'of' when introducing the object of the fear.
Tenses
The managers were candid. They didn’t merely discuss job roles; they ______ profound anxieties, particularly the fear of losing their professional identity.
Show answer & why
articulated · 💡 The narrative is in the past tense ('were candid', 'didn't discuss'), so the simple past 'articulated' is required to maintain tense consistency.
Grammar in contextself-check
Three primary themes emerged. First: job security is paramount, but more importantly, they seek to feel ______ indispensable.
Show answer & why
no article · 💡 The adjective 'indispensable' is used predicatively here to describe a state of being. No article is needed before a predicative adjective unless it modifies a specific noun.
Verb forms
Did you explore potential future roles with them? Yes. We presented preliminary concepts... We ______ them, 'We aren’t eliminating positions; we’re evolving them.'
Show answer & why
assured · 💡 The context describes a completed action in the past ('We presented...'). The simple past 'assured' is the correct tense to match the narrative sequence of events.
Tenses
That’s encouraging. It signals growing trust in the process. Did you identify potential change ambassadors? Indeed. Some even ______ to co-author the new job descriptions.
Show answer & why
volunteered · 💡 The narrative is in the past tense ('It signals', 'Did you identify'). The action of volunteering occurred during the meeting described, so the simple past 'volunteered' is appropriate.
Prepositionsself-check
Alex Vance: That aligns perfectly ______ our objectives. Our messaging must now emphasize, 'Your contribution remains vital as we transition.'
Show answer & why
with · 💡 The verb 'align' is commonly used with the preposition 'with' to indicate agreement or compatibility with a standard or goal ('align with objectives').
Discussion (practise speaking)
How can managers address the fear of losing professional identity during organizational transitions?
🤔 Think about a time when you felt uncertain about your role during a change-how did you cope?
Show sample answer
- Acknowledge anxieties directly rather than dismissing them.
- Provide clarity on what remains constant in the new structure.
- Involve employees in shaping their evolving roles to maintain a sense of value.
Vocabulary
- job security
- ↗
reveal definition
The assurance that one will not lose their current position. “First: job security is paramount, but more importantly, they seek to feel indispensable.” - change ambassadors
- ↗
reveal definition
Employees who help promote and support organizational change. “Did you identify potential change ambassadors?” - change network
- ↗
reveal definition
A group of individuals who facilitate and support change initiatives. “They’ve agreed to join the change network.” - talent team
- ↗
reveal definition
The HR or recruitment department responsible for managing employee development. “I’ll enlist our Talent team to support them.” - adoption rates
- ↗
reveal definition
The speed or extent to which users begin using a new system or process. “We’re monitoring adoption rates.” - reporting structure
- ↗
reveal definition
The hierarchy or framework defining how employees report to one another. “some department heads are still unclear about the new reporting structure.” - senior management
- ↗
reveal definition
High-level executives who make strategic decisions for the organization. “We just need buy-in from senior management in Hillcrest and Eastgate.” - escalation procedures
- ↗
reveal definition
Formal steps for handling issues that cannot be resolved at a lower level. “clear escalation procedures.”
Key phrases (useful expressions from the dialogue)
- reconvene so soon To meet again after a short period of time.
- surpassing our expectations To perform better than anticipated or hoped for.
- feel indispensable To believe that one’s role is absolutely necessary and cannot be replaced.
- retain autonomy To maintain the ability to make independent decisions within one’s role.
- co-author the new To help write or create new job descriptions together with others.
- gaining traction To become more successful or widely accepted over time.
More HR & Recruitment lessons
Airline Pilot Interview and Radio Communication Test
A candidate undergoes a simulated airline interview and radio communication assessment to evaluate aviation vo…
Conducting a Performance Review with a Stock Team Leader
An assistant manager meets with a senior stock associate to evaluate team performance ahead of the holiday rus…
Discussing Career Transition with a Headhunter
A legal professional meets with a headhunter to explore new career opportunities after leaving a senior role. …
Executive Interview for Regional Operations Director
An executive candidate interviews for a regional operations director role, discussing leadership style and pas…
First-Round Leadership Interview at Consulting Firm
An HR Director conducts a first-round interview with a candidate for a Director of Strategy & Transformation r…
Global Commercial Director Interview for Renewable Energy Expansion
A multinational renewable energy company conducts a final interview for a Global Commercial Director role to l…
Keep going
Practise this scenario live with Phil, and get a personalised lesson built from your own mistakes. Interactive in the browser, with a booklet to keep.
Book a lesson with Phil